Pools or Hot Tubs, which should I get? Or should I get both?

That’s a tricky question, as pools and hot tubs both have their pros and cons. There are so many things to consider, like space, cost, use, value, climate, etc.

I live in a warm climate, so I went with my cool, refreshing pool first! Hot tubs are more relaxing, especially in the winter. So, after about 3 years with my swimming pool, I got my hot tub.

Maybe I should have stuck with just one. Maintaining the two takes up a lot of my time and energy. I don’t want to talk about the bills!

Dive Into the World of Pools and Hot Tubs Choices

Choosing between a pool, a hot tub, or splurging on both depends on several factors, including your lifestyle, budget, space, and what you’re looking to get out of the experience. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:


  • Pros: Great for exercise, swimming laps, and playing with friends and family, can cool you down on hot days.
  • Cons: Takes up a lot of space, is expensive to install and maintain, limited use in colder climates.

Hot Tubs:

  • Pros: Relaxing and therapeutic, usable year-round, comparatively lower cost and maintenance, space-saving options available.
  • Cons: Limited to soaking and isn’t ideal for exercise or large gatherings.

Getting Both:

Pool n hot tub

Having both a pool and a hot tub is ideal but requires significant space and budget.

Here are some additional factors to consider:

  • Climate: Pools are best suited for warm climates where you can use them for most of the year. Hot tubs are great for year-round use.
  • Space: Pools take up a lot of space, while hot tubs come in various sizes to fit smaller yards.
  • Budget: Pools are generally more expensive than hot tubs in terms of installation and maintenance.
  • Usage: Consider how you’ll be using it. If exercise is a priority, a pool might be better. For relaxation, a hot tub is a good choice.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your needs. If you’re still unsure, consider these options:

  • Start with a hot tub: They’re more affordable and space-saving. You can always add a pool later. Or, start with a pool for cooling off and family fun (maybe), then think of a hot tub.
  • Explore a swim spa: This combines the features of a pool and hot tub, offering a small swimming area and hot water jets.
Pools and hot tubs

A pool with a hot tub

Let’s lay out the pros and cons of getting pools versus hot tubs on a straightforward table. This will help you compare them side by side and make an informed decision based on what’s most important to you.

WordPress Tables Plugin

This comparison shows that pools are fantastic for fitness, fun, and entertaining larger groups, but they come with higher costs and maintenance needs. On the flip side, hot tubs offer year-round relaxation and therapeutic benefits in a more intimate setting, with generally lower initial and ongoing costs, though they, too, require regular maintenance.

Why Get A Pool – Factors to Consider

Installing a pool can be a fantastic way to enhance your property and lifestyle, but it’s a significant investment. Here are some key factors to consider before taking the plunge:

Benefits of Owning a Pool:

  • Fun and Recreation: Pools provide a cool escape on hot days, a place for splashy games with friends and family, and a perfect spot for pool parties.
  • Exercise and Health: Swimming is a fantastic low-impact exercise, offering full-body workout, improved cardiovascular health, and stress relief.
  • Increased Property Value: In some areas, a pool can add value to your home, especially if it’s well-maintained and complements your landscaping.

Factors to Consider Before Getting a Pool:

  • Cost: Be honest about your budget. Pools are expensive, with costs encompassing installation, materials, ongoing maintenance (chemicals, cleaning), and potential utilities for heating. Factor in fencing if required by local regulations.
  • Space: Pools take up a considerable amount of space. Consider the size of your yard, ensuring enough space for lounging areas and safety clearances.
  • Use: You need to think about how often and for what purposes you will use your pool. Do you want it for exercise, relaxation, entertainment, or therapy? Do you have a family or guests who will use it as well? Do you want to use it year-round or only in certain seasons? These factors will affect the design, features, and heating options of your pool.
  • Maintenance: Pools require regular cleaning, chemical balancing, and equipment upkeep. Are you prepared to dedicate time and effort to maintaining pool health throughout the year?
  • Climate: Pools are ideal for warm climates where you can enjoy them for a large part of the year. In colder regions, usability is limited, and closing procedures add another layer of maintenance.
  • Local Regulations: Check with your local municipality for any permits, fencing requirements, or specific safety codes needed for pool installation.
  • Types of Pools: There are different types of pools to consider, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Here are some common types: Inground Concrete Pools, Inground Fiberglass Pools, Inground Vinyl Liner Pools, Above-Ground Pools, etc.

By carefully considering these factors, you can make an informed decision about whether a pool is the right fit for your needs and lifestyle.

Above ground pool - Metal Frame

An above ground pool

Read more:-

20 Types of Pools

Above Ground Pool Types

Above ground Pools – A guide

Why Get A Hot Tub – Factors to Consider

Are hot tubs worth it

Hot tubs offer a unique set of advantages that can greatly enhance your well-being and create a relaxing haven in your own backyard. Here’s a breakdown of why you might consider getting a hot tub:

Benefits of Owning a Hot Tub:

  • Relaxation and Stress Relief: Hot water therapy is a well-known way to soothe sore muscles, ease tension headaches, and melt away stress. The combination of warmth and massaging jets can leave you feeling rejuvenated.
  • Improved Sleep: Soaking in a hot tub before bed can raise your body temperature and promote a natural drop afterward, mimicking the body’s natural sleep cycle and potentially leading to better sleep quality.
  • Pain Management: The warmth and buoyancy of a hot tub can help alleviate pain caused by arthritis, muscle soreness, and injuries. Hydrotherapy can also improve circulation, further aiding in pain relief.
  • Social Connection: Hot tubs provide a cozy and inviting space for social gatherings with friends and family. Imagine enjoying a conversation under the stars with loved ones, all while soaking in the warm water.
  • Year-Round Use: Unlike pools, hot tubs can be enjoyed year-round. The heated water provides a welcome escape from the cold winter months, while still being enjoyable on cooler summer evenings.

Additional Factors to Consider:

  • Space: Hot tubs come in various sizes, making them a viable option for even smaller backyards. They can be strategically placed on patios or decks, creating a cozy retreat.
  • Cost: Compared to pools, hot tubs are generally less expensive in terms of initial investment and ongoing maintenance. The hot tub’s size, features, and energy efficiency will impact the overall cost.
  • Use: You need to think about how often and for what purposes you will use your hot tub. Do you want it for relaxation, therapy, entertainment, or fitness? Do you have a family or guests who will use it as well? Do you want to use it year-round or only in certain seasons? These factors will affect your hot tub’s design, features, and heating options.
  • Maintenance: While not as demanding as pools, hot tubs still require regular maintenance, including water chemistry checks, cleaning, and occasional filter changes.
  • Lifestyle: Consider how you would use a hot tub. If relaxation and stress relief are priorities, a hot tub might be ideal. If you crave exercise and large gatherings, a pool might be a better fit.
  • Types of Hot Tubs: There are different types of hot tubs available, each with its own advantages and disadvantages, such as acrylic, inflatable, and swim spas.

By weighing these benefits and considering your lifestyle, you can determine if a hot tub is the perfect addition to your home for relaxation, social connection, and improved well-being.

Read more:-

Types of Hot Tubs

Why buy a hot tub?

Are hot tubs worth it?

How Much Does it Cost to Run a Hot Tub?

Where do Walk-in Bathtubs Fall in the Conversation About Pools and Hot Tubs?

Walk in tub

Walk-in bathtubs are left out of the conversation about pools and hot tubs because they serve entirely different purposes. Pools and hot tubs are for leisure and relaxation, while walk-in bathtubs are accessibility and safety features for bathrooms.

Read more about walk-in bathtubs here.

Final Thoughts – Pools or Hot Tubs

Deciding between a pool and a hot tub is like choosing between a beach vacation and a mountain retreat; both have their unique allure and benefits. Your choice hinges on what you value most in your relaxation and leisure time.

A pool might be your ideal choice if you lean towards active recreation, value physical fitness, and enjoy hosting gatherings where everyone can splash and play.

Conversely, a hot tub could be the perfect addition to your home if you’re seeking a more intimate setting for relaxation, therapeutic benefits for health, and a cozy place to unwind, no matter the season.

Some might consider blending the best of both worlds by incorporating a pool and a hot tub into their outdoor living space. This combination caters to a wider range of activities, from invigorating laps in the pool to serene relaxation in the hot tub.